← All guides

MLM vs pyramid scheme: the legal difference, explained

Goran Stanić

By Goran Stanić

7 min read · Updated November 22, 2026

The legal difference is where the money comes from. A legitimate multi-level marketing company pays its distributors mainly for products sold to real customers who want them. A pyramid scheme pays mainly for recruiting: people buy in for the right to earn from bringing in others, and the rewards aren't tied to sales to real users. The FTC's consumer guidance puts it simply: "In a legitimate MLM program, you should be able to make money just by selling the product."

The legal test (Koscot)

US courts use the test from the FTC's 1975 Koscot case. A pyramid scheme is "characterized by the payment by participants of money to the company in return for which they receive (1) the right to sell a product and (2) the right to receive in return for recruiting other participants into the program rewards which are unrelated to sale of the product to ultimate users."

In plain words: if people pay to join and the real money is in recruiting, not in selling to people who want the product, it's a pyramid scheme.

What the FTC looks at

From the FTC's Business Guidance Concerning Multi-Level Marketing (April 2024):

  • "There is no percentage-based test to determine whether an MLM is a pyramid scheme." It looks at how the whole plan works.
  • "An MLM can sell real, even high-quality, products or services and still be a pyramid scheme." Good products don't settle it.
  • "Having retail customers or even many retail customers is not a safe harbor."
  • Purchases by distributors themselves can be a problem when they're made "for reasons unrelated to their own actual demand or their customers' genuine retail demand", for example to qualify for bonuses.

The FTC's consumer page adds the warning signs: income "based mostly on how many people you recruit, not how much product you sell", and distributors buying products "just to stay active in the company or to qualify for bonuses or other rewards".

Real cases

  • BurnLounge (2014): a federal appeals court upheld the finding that BurnLounge's program was a pyramid scheme, because its rewards were driven by recruiting. The court also said: "Not all MLM businesses are illegal pyramid schemes."
  • Vemma (2015): a federal court found "little doubt" the FTC would show Vemma was operating a pyramid scheme, and said an ultimate user is someone "who would have purchased a product even if not for the income opportunity".
  • Herbalife (2016) and Amway (2026) settled FTC actions by changing how they pay; see Herbalife and Amway.

How to check a company yourself

  • Read the compensation plan: are rewards tied to sales to customers, or to recruiting and buying?
  • Read the income disclosure: see how to read one.
  • Ask whether you'd buy the products at that price without the business attached.
  • Check for red flags and search the FTC's website for the company's name.

When a prospect asks "is this a pyramid scheme?", an honest answer helps; see how to answer it. This page explains the law in general and isn't legal advice.

Sources

Quick answers

What is the difference between MLM and a pyramid scheme?
A legitimate MLM pays mainly for products sold to real customers; a pyramid scheme pays mainly for recruiting, with rewards unrelated to sales to real users.
Is MLM legal in the US?
Yes, when pay comes from real product sales to people who want them. Plans that pay mainly for recruiting are illegal pyramid schemes.
Does selling real products make an MLM legal?
Not by itself. The FTC says an MLM can sell real, high-quality products and still be a pyramid scheme if pay is driven by recruiting.
What is the Koscot test?
The legal test from the FTC’s 1975 Koscot case: people pay to join for the right to sell and the right to earn from recruiting, with rewards unrelated to sales to ultimate users.

Update history

  • November 22, 2026: First published. Read the FTC’s Business Guidance Concerning Multi-Level Marketing (April 2024), its consumer page, and the BurnLounge and Vemma court documents that day.
Goran Stanić

Goran Stanić

Network marketer, DownlineAI

Goran has worked in network marketing for more than 20 years and has led teams of over 1,000 people across his career.

How we write and check our guides